10 images

Bourke Street Bakery, Sydney

Despite its large, untraditional structure, which is more of a loaf, Bourke Street Bakery's hot cross bun ticked all the judges' boxes. "Love the old-fashioned flavour," said Pignolet. "Good texture and taste. Nice crumb." Thé gave it two thumbs-up for technique. "The yeast is just perfectly proved and the baking's great." Nourse said: "You're going to cut that into a slice, you're going to put that in the toaster and you're going to be a very happy person." $6.50 a loaf.


Hot cross buns taste test

We skipped breakfast, rolled up our sleeves and took on the task of taste-testing hot cross buns in the name of retail research. Maya Kerthyasa shares the verdict.

This time of year brings plenty of good things, not least the prospect of hot cross buns. While keen home bakers make their own (and there's no shortage of details on our website), many of us turn to bakeries, grocery stores and supermarkets for our fix. These days the shelves are bursting with choice, which is why we decided to road-test 10 of the more classic specimens from different ends of the retail spectrum.

The panel of judges - Christopher Thé of Sydney's Black Star Pastry (a keen bun-maker himself), chef and Gourmet Traveller masterclass contributor Damien Pignolet, our own senior food editor Lisa Featherby, and chief restaurant critic Pat Nourse - blind-tasted each one, looking for buns that were soft and giving with a rich colour, consistent structure and balanced levels of fruit and spice. Most importantly, though, they were looking for buns they'd be happy to serve on their Easter table.

Did they find them? You'll want to flick on the toaster and get the butter out of the fridge - the results were surprising. Here are their findings, starting with the buns they rated most highly.

Note The buns from Flour and Stone, Jocelyn's Provisions and Coles arrived a day before the tasting; our tasters were made aware of this during the tasting.

Photography Ben Hansen Styling Lisa Featherby

Healthy Eating

We're championing fresh food that packs a flavour punch, from salads and vegetable-packed bowls to grains and light desserts.

Subscribe to Gourmet

Subscribe to Australian Gourmet Traveller and receive a free salt and pepper set - offer ends 26 March, 2017

Gourmet digital

Subscribe to Gourmet Traveller for your iPad or Android tablet.

Flour and Stone Recipes

Baker extraordinaire Nadine Ingram of Sydney's Flour and Stone cooks up a sweet storm for Easter, including the much loved bakery's greatest hit.

Fast autumn dinners

Autumn weather signals the arrival of soups, broths, roasts and more hearty meals.

Roasted cauliflower salad with yoghurt dressing and almonds

The cauliflower is roasted until it starts to caramelise, which adds extra depth of flavour to this winning salad. Serve it warm or at room temperature.

Savoury tarts

Will your next baking project be a flaky puff pastry with pumpkin, goat's curd and thyme, or a classic bacon and Stilton tart? As autumn settles in, we're ticking these off one by one.

Melbournes finest meet Worlds Best

Leading chefs descend on Melbourne in April for The World’s 50 Best Restaurants. We asked local hospitality folk who they’d abduct for the day and where they’d take them to show off their city. There may be coffee, there may be culture, but in the end it’s cocktails.

1980s recipes

Australia saw some bold moves in the ’80s, and we’re not just talking hairstyles. Greater cultural references started peppering the menus of our restaurants, and home-grown ingredients won a new appreciation. The dining scene was coming of age and a new band of pioneers led the charge.

New cruises 2017

Cue the Champagne.

Roti canai

Here, we've made the dough in a food processor, but it's really quick and simple to do by hand as well. If the dough seems a little too wet just add a little more flour.

more collections

Email your friend

Send this link to your friend or yourself via email.

get the latest news

Sign up to receive the latest food, travel and dining news direct from Gourmet Traveller headquarters.