Good food, bad waiter. Should I tip?

Do I leave a tip if the food's good, but the waiter's lousy?
By Guy

Pat Nourse, Gourmet Traveller restaurant critic, writes:
"Tricky. Short of slipping a note over the pass into the kitchen on your way out or hiding it under a mound of uneaten cavolo nero, or having a face-off with your waiter, asking them to take the tip directly to the chef and not collect x-dollars themselves, you’ve got the choice of: (a) not tipping at all, aka the lose-lose strategy, telling yourself that the waiters are really the face of the kitchen and it’s their problem, or (b) tipping and hoping some fraction of your gratuity makes it back-of-house.


Tipping really is for service, though, and it’s the rare restaurant that kicks back tips all the way to the kitchen. I say take the scorched earth approach: regardless of your good intentions, tipping your bad waiter is rewarding poor performance, and that’s never a good policy. Stiff ‘em and, if you feel so moved, order the kitchen a nice bottle or some beers before you settle, slip some money to the maitre d’ for the kitchen on the way out, or send the chef a note of thanks and a gratuity in the post." 


GT
Signature Collection

Find out more about the Gourmet Traveller Signature Collection by Robert Gordon Australia, including where to buy it in store and online.

Read More
Recipe collections

Looking for fresh dinner ideas? Not sure how to make the most out of seasonal produce? Or do you need to plan the perfect party menu? Our recipe collections have you covered.

See more

You might also like...

Albert Street Food & Wine

Philippa Sibley may have left the building, but Albert St F...

Aravina Estate

The family-friendly nature of Aravina explains the terracot...

Assaggio

Assaggio's very red, very mod fit-out has undeniable flair,...

Annie Smithers' Bistrot

Annie Smithers may have decamped for Du Fermier, but the bi...

Bacchus - Brisbane

Rydges doesn't exactly leap to mind when you think "complex...

Balla

Pronounce it "bah-la" for Piedmont-born artist and composer...

Balthazar

The mixing of business and pleasure comes second nature to ...

Boucher

Escargots, foie gras, bouillabaisse - the expected French s...

Celsius

A land of smoke and mirrors, Celsius is an urbane, nightclu...

Citron

Mark Newman's cassia beef cheek is the type of dish that ce...

Divido

To those who dream of the old country, Divido is the modern...

David’s

David's hums with renewed energy since its transformation t...

Eleonore’s

On the surface, Eleonore's seems immune to fashion. Its lar...

E'cco

Two decades is a long time to stay on top of your game in t...

Flooded Gums

A fine scallop boudin blanc paired with charred squid and a...