Browse All Recipes

Hot buttered lobster rolls

Why not turn the lobster roll into a transseasonal snack by serving them hot?

By Lisa Featherby
  • 30 mins preparation
  • 25 mins cooking plus standing
  • Serves 6
  • Print
A classic lobster roll is always a crowd-pleaser.


  • 3 small live lobsters (450gm each)
  • 8 hotdog rolls, sides trimmed, pocket cut into the top lengthways
  • Thinly sliced chives, to serve
Brown butter sauce
  • 150 gm unsalted butter, plus extra for greasing
  • 2 garlic cloves, crushed
  • 1-2 tbsp lemon juice, or to taste
  • ¼ tsp smoked paprika, cayenne or chipotle powder (see note), plus extra to serve


  • 1
    Place lobsters in freezer to render them insensible (30 minutes), then split lengthways through the head. Cook lobsters in a large saucepan of rapidly boiling salted water (4 minutes), then refresh in iced water. Drain, then, when cool enough to handle, separate tail and head by twisting and pulling in opposite directions. Remove meat from tails and legs, coarsely chop tail meat and refrigerate until required.
  • 2
    For brown butter sauce, cook butter in a saucepan over high heat until browned (3-4 minutes). Add garlic, lemon and paprika, season to taste and keep warm.
  • 3
    Butter sides of rolls and fry in a frying pan over high heat, turning, until golden (1-2 minutes each side). Keep warm.
  • 4
    Add lobster to saucepan with brown butter sauce and stir over low heat to warm through. Spoon into rolls and top with chives and paprika to serve.


Powdered chipotle – smoked chilli – is available from Herbie's Spices.
The RSPCA's advice for killing crustaceans humanely are to render the animals insensible by placing them in the freezer (under 4C) until the tail or outer mouth parts can be moved without resistance; crustaceans must then be killed quickly by cutting through the centreline of the head and thorax.